Mahira Khan, widely celebrated as one of Pakistan’s most successful actresses, is facing pointed criticism despite the commercial triumph of her latest film, “Love Guru.” The movie has been confirmed as the biggest box office hit of the year, further cementing her status as a top-tier star who has achieved recognition both domestically and on international platforms. However, this commercial success has been met with a dissenting critical voice.
Commentator Nazia Malik has publicly scrutinized Khan’s performance, stating that the actress appeared “flat” on screen in her role as Sophia Khan. Malik argued that Khan’s sustained stardom is less about her acting talent and more a result of “good luck.” She expanded her critique beyond this single film, referencing Khan’s Punjabi dialect in the blockbuster “The Legend of Maula Jatt” as another example of what she perceives as a lack of preparation or consistency in the actor’s performances.
Adding a personal dimension to her critique, Malik also commented on Khan’s physical appearance in “Love Guru,” observing noticeable weight fluctuations between different scenes. She praised actresses Ayesha Omar and Ushna Shah for their disciplined physique maintenance, presenting them as role models in an industry where appearance is often highlighted. These comments have ignited a broader discussion among netizens and film enthusiasts about the nature of artistic critique, the pressures on female actors, and the separation between box office success and critical performance appraisal.
